July 28, 2008

New Acropolis Museum due to open in October but without its star attraction

Posted at 12:53 pm in Elgin Marbles, New Acropolis Museum

The New Acropolis Museum in Athens is due to open imminently. Unfortunately though, there is still no sign of its star exhibits being there for the opening.


Acropolis now
Athens’s new museum is spectacular, even without its star exhibits. Kevin Rushby gets a sneak preview
Kevin Rushby, The Guardian, Saturday July 26 2008

Walking through bright sunshine and crowds of tourists in an Athenian street, I glanced down and read the publicity blurb in my hand. The story was there, contained in just a few words: “Museum mission: to house all the surviving antiquities from the Acropolis within a single museum of international stature.” Actually the entire story is distilled into one word: ALL. But they might have added that it has been a 207-year mission to return the so-called Elgin Marbles – the first being cut down from the Parthenon on July 31, 1801.

A little further up the road and both buildings are in sight: to my right, rising from a skirt of trees, is the knobbly hill of the Acropolis, crowned by the Parthenon; to my left, behind some low buildings, is the New Acropolis Museum. The international stature of the Parthenon requires no words, but does this new museum live up to the lofty ambition? And the big question: does it have the requisite stature even when ALL the antiquities are not present – because half of them are in London?

The approach is promising. As we take the steps up to the museum entrance, the ground to our left suddenly falls away to reveal archaeological excavations. This is a part of ancient Athens dating back to the 5th century BC, an area contemporary with the construction of the Parthenon itself. It was this discovery that delayed the project for so long, but the architect, Bernard Tschumi, solved the problem in spectacular style – by setting the building on more than 100 concrete pillars directly over the old city. Not only that but the floor of the museum is largely glass: wherever you walk on the lower and middle levels of the building, you have the sensation of walking through those ancient streets. The illusion is shattered only when you ascend to the upper floor where the marbles themselves are kept.

The marbles, of course, are the raison d’être for this £100m project. Here’s a quick recap of the situation. In 480BC the Persians invaded Greece and sacked the Acropolis, the hill that stands over the city of Athens and houses its sacred sites. A generation later the Athenians, led by Pericles, decided to celebrate their city’s revival in fortunes by rebuilding the Parthenon, the temple to Athena in her virginal state. The sculptor Phideas produced an astonishing stone frieze running for 547ft around the architrave of the building – an artistic achievement of staggering size and quality, a distillation of what the first Greek democracy could produce.

The marble frieze subsequently survived the decline and fall of Hellenic culture, the Roman Empire, the Goths and the Ottoman Turks. It survived everything, in fact, until 1801, when the seventh Earl of Elgin arrived. Armed with some dodgy paperwork, a chestful of baksheesh and several saws, Elgin had about half of the frieze cut off and shipped home, along with a multitude of other carvings and statues. His motivation was clear. “My house in Scotland,” he wrote to his Athenian agent, “. . . offers me the means of placing, in a useful, distinguished, and agreeable way, the various things that you may perhaps be able to procure for me.” Grand designs, indeed. Elgin was a DIY enthusiast, though an overspent one, and after much haggling the marbles were sold to the British Museum for £35,000.

Since then it has been one-way criticism, from Lord Byron to Merlina Mercouri, without result. The hill did have a museum for what remained after plunderers, but with new and significant finds from the whole Acropolis site, that had long ago become too small. In particular there was a number of well-preserved statues from the pre-480BC Acropolis, some showing clear traces of the paint that once adorned them. Finally the Greeks have hit upon a brilliant strategy: build a gigantic home for the marbles and all this extra Acropolis treasure, push it under the noses of the Trojans, sorry British, and wait for their hard hearts and barren minds to be moved.

So as I walked up to the upper floor of the new museum and stepped through the door, the question in my mind was: What if those hearts are not moved? Does the New Acropolis Museum warrant a visit, even without several of its star exhibits?

The first thing you see as you pass through that door is, appropriately, the Parthenon, rising up above the surrounding city and no further away than a hero could heave a discus. Then you notice that the gallery runs around the central core of the building which has risen from the ground floor and is itself precisely the same dimensions as the Parthenon. It is on this core that the marbles are placed. Currently about half are original and half are plaster copies, and this is far from ideal but nevertheless does give, for the first time in two centuries, a chance to see the whole of Phideas’s astonishing artistic achievement.

“The frieze is one narrative,” says Professor Dimitrios Pandermalis, curator of the museum. “It tells the story of the presentation of the most important Athenian feast to honour the goddess of the city, Athena. For the first time all the groups of Athenian society, the common people and officials, are presented in a democratic way on a similar level as the gods.”

Not only that but the visitor, for the first time, can stroll around the entire narrative of the frieze at eye-level, examining the detail. And there is plenty of detail. The British Museum misguidedly restored Elgin’s marbles in the 1930s, scouring away the natural weathered patina and fragments of original paint to reach a white finish, a finish that is unnatural to the stone itself. The Greek marbles retain that patina. Further sculptures in the museum, from the pre-480BC Acropolis, show signs of that original paint, miraculously preserved.

The new museum is undoubtedly going to be a huge tourist attraction. Its breathtaking design, with natural light flooding every corner, is a huge achievement in itself. And with every visitor, I am sure, another voice will be raised to call on London to restore the unity of this astonishing piece of art.

· The lower sculpture galleries of the New Acropolis Museum (newacropolismuseum.gr) are now accessible to the public; the entire building should open officially in mid-October. Aegean Airlines (aegeanair.com) flies daily from Stansted to Athens from around £100 rtn in mid-October. Rooms at Hermes Hotel have full sliding windows on to tiny balconies that look down on a narrow street, or the Acropolis; doubles from €145 through i-escape.com.

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

Possibly related articles

Tags: , , , , , , , ,


  1. Vera Marie Badertscher said,

    07.28.08 at 8:15 pm

    Just found this impressive site. Thank you for your work.

    In May, I visited the British Museum for the first time (I am an American) and 48 hours later I was in the New Acropolis Museum. I was privileged to get a preview tour because I am a travel writer. The new Athens building is, as you say, a breath-taking museum and the exhibits take a grand poke at the British Museum.

    A great deal has been written about the intransegence of the British Museum trustees, but I haven’t seen mentioned that fact that the Parthenon room is the most heavily visited of all the magnificent rooms in the Museum. Although once people get a look at the New Acropolis Museum, they may decide the Brit is actually not all that well done. But because the room is such a draw, surely they would not only lose face, but also money, by returning the marbles?

    The official arguments given by the tour guides whom I hectored during two tours of the room, are entirely feeble and do not hold water. American museums have been busy giving back ill-gotten gains to Native American nations. Not everything goes back. The museums are not decimated. Surely the Brit could learn something from the example of museums like the Smithsonian.


  2. Matthew said,

    07.29.08 at 1:03 pm

    The Duveen Gallery may be one of the more visited galleries in the British Museum, but I have never seen any evidence to suggest that it is the most visited gallery there. William G Stewart commissioned some research to count visitors entering the gallery in the late 1990s. I remember that it was only a small proportion of the total that flowed through the museum in the same time period, but I don’t have the exact figures to hand at the moment (of course, this survey took place before the major reorganisation of the museum’s circulation brought about by opening up the Great Court, so the results could be significantly different now.

    The British Museum have many other artefacts that are not currently on display that could be located in the gallery. There have also been offers from Greece to supply artefacts for a series of temporary exhibitions.

    As the British Museum is free admission, visitor numbers have no direct affect on profitability. Most funding comes as as Grant in Aid from the Department of Culture, Media & Sport.

    On the other hand, temporary exhibitions are the most significant money earner for the museum, as well as the biggest incentive for people to make repeat visits – so with offers of artefacts to be used to create temporary exhibitions in the space, it could be a win-win situation, with both sides benefiting in different ways.

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URL

Leave a Comment

We want to hear your views. Be as critical or controversial as you like, but please don't get personal or offensive. Remember this is for feedback and constructive discussion!
Comments may be edited or removed if they do not meet these guidelines. Repeat offenders will be blocked from posting further comments. Any comment deemed libellous by Elginism's editors will be removed.
The commenting system uses some automatic spam detection and occasionally comments do not appear instantly - please do not repost comments if they do not show up straight away