October 13, 2009
In the past, Egypt’s Zahi Hawass has asked for the return of disputed artefacts in the Louvre. Now, as a means to escalate the issue, he is trhreatening to withdraw any co-operation between Egypt & the Louvre until the issue is resolved.
Agence France Presse
Egypt breaks ties with France’s Louvre Museum
By Christophe de Roquefeuil (AFP)
7th October 2009
CAIRO — Egypt announced on Wednesday that it has cut all cooperation with France’s Louvre Museum until it secures the return of “stolen” Pharaonic antiquities in the latest row involving the exhibits of a major European institution.
“We made the decision to end any cooperation with the Louvre until they return” the works, antiquities chief Zahi Hawass told AFP.
He charged that the renowned Paris museum had bought the antiquities in 1980 even though its curators knew they were stolen.
“The purchase of stolen steles is a sign that some museums are prepared to encourage the destruction and theft of Egyptian antiquities,” he said.
French sources said that the antiquities Egypt was demanding were decorative fragments from a tomb in the Valley of the Kings near Luxor.
The Louvre said it was open to the idea of returning the works but that the decision was not the museum’s alone.
“The process for returning them has been engaged,” a member of the Louvre’s executive told AFP on condition of anonymity.
“But the decision is not for the museum to take because in order to return the works, we would need the agreement of the National Scientific Commission for the Museum Collections of France,” he said.
The commission is due to meet by the end of the week to discuss removing the steles from the Louvre, where they are on display.
If the panel does decide to send them back to Egypt, the culture ministry must also give the green light. France ‘to return’ Egypt relics
Egypt’s decision to suspend cooperation will affect conferences organised with the museum, as well as work carried out by the Louvre on the Pharaonic necropolis of Saqqara, south of the capital Cairo.
Hawass said it had been taken two months ago, implying that it had nothing to do with Egyptian unhappiness over the defeat of Culture Minister Faruq Hosni in the race to become the new director of the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO) last month.
A French source said the atmosphere created by Hosni’s defeat “doesn’t help,” but insisted that “there is no real obstacle and a solution should be found soon.”
A number of the world’s most famous museums have collections of Egyptian antiquities, many of them acquired during British colonial rule.
But in recent years the Egyptian authorities have been increasingly vociferous in campaigning for the return of important works.
In 2007, French authorities returned to Egypt an ancient pharaoh’s hairs that were nearly sold on the Internet by a French postal worker whose father had acquired them during the scientific examination of the royal mummy 30 years previously.
The case prompted Egyptian authorities to bar foreign scientists from examining royal mummies.
Egypt has also long demanded the return from Berlin of a bust of the legendary Queen Nefertiti that was discovered on the banks of the Nile by German archaeologist Ludwig Borchardt in December 1912.
The case mirrors that of the so-called Elgin Marbles, the decorative frieze that used to adorn the Parthenon in Athens whose return by the British Museum in London Greece has long demanded.
- Louvre returns ancient artefacts to Egypt : December 26, 2009
- Egypt battles to secure more artefact returns after Louvre success : October 23, 2009
- Further details on Egypt’s stolen antiquities conference : January 6, 2010
- Egyptian art returns from France : December 26, 2009
- Louvre to return some Egyptian artefacts : October 21, 2009
- Egypt calls for unity over looted antiquities : May 25, 2010
- Hawass claims that the Louvre knew Egyptian artefacts were looted : October 13, 2009
- Ancient Pharaoh’s hair returned to Egypt : April 11, 2007