November 28, 2012
“Back to the county where it belongs” (Perhaps we call it “cultural regionalism”) versus “Cultural nationalism”
Yet again, we see an example, where campaigns to keep items in the area where they were found are praised as a great thing, whereas campaigns for the return of looted artefacts are decried as cultural nationalism.
I have no particular objection to the first part – but if we follow this path, then we must somehow find a way to stop objecting to the second part – there is no reason why the cases should be treated in a completely different way depending on which side of the fence we find ourselves in the argument. M any of the cases like this that crop up are within a country – but this still makes them not much different from the Lewis Chessmen, the Mold Cape, or the Lindisfarne Gospels.
What makes the whole situation even less logical, is that many of the items that have been the subject of cultural regionalism have very little to actually tie them to the region where they were found. Often, they are lose items like coins or jewelry that could have been transported anywhere. We have little idea of who they belonged to, or quite how they ended up where they did. Compare such cases to that of the Parthenon Marbles – purpose designed and carved to be seen in a specific way on a specific building in a specific location. The context in their cases was everything – they were never like a painting or small statue to be moved around, but as much a part of the building as the columns, walls, floor or roof.
Worcestershire Hoard will come back to the county for good
2:50pm Tuesday 27th November 2012 in News
MUSEUMS Worcestershire is delighted that the appeal to raise funds to acquire the Worcestershire Hoard has been successful and the hoard will now come back to the county where it belongs.
Efforts to raise funds to conserve and display the coins will continue into the New Year.
Just over a year ago Worcestershire hit the headlines with the discovery of the largest haul of treasure ever found in the county, a stash of almost 4,000 Roman coins discovered by two metal detecting enthusiasts, including Jethro Carpenter from Redditch, in the Vale of Evesham on Bredon Hill.
Research undertaken by Worcestershire Archaeology and Archives Service with the British Museum indicates the hoard was buried nearly a century after it was accumulated – the only known such British example – meaning the Worcestershire hoard is unique and of national significance.
More than £4,500 was raised through private donations, Worcestershire Archaeological Society also greatly boosted the fund by donating more than £1,000 to the appeal, and it has now been confirmed that an application to the V&A Purchase Grant Fund has been successful, which means a total of £9,000 has been raised to acquire the hoard.
The appeal will now continue to raise the remaining £30,000 needed to conserve and display the Hoard across the county.
Residents can still offer their support and make a donation by visiting the online giving page http://charitychoice.co.uk/worcestershire-hoard/ or by visiting the Museums Worcestershire website http://museumsworcestershire.org.uk Also by texting COIN11 and the amount of money to 70070, e.g. COIN11 £5 to donate £5, or by popping into the Worcester City Art Gallery and Museum, the Commandery in Worcester or the County Museum at Hartlebury.
- Saving for the nation versus “cultural nationalism” : October 17, 2012
- Frome Hoard to remain in Somerset : November 10, 2011
- The magic is lost when an artefact is taken from its geographical context : January 19, 2010
- The importance of documented archaeological excavations : December 19, 2012
- Frome Hoard returns to Somerset : March 17, 2012
- Staffordshire Hoard saved from the nation : May 20, 2010
- Why keeping artefacts locally makes sense to Britain’s Cuture Minister : October 11, 2009
- The Elgin Coins? : July 22, 2009