January 29, 2008

California museum fraud raids suggest deeper issues

Posted at 1:29 pm in Similar cases

The raids on various museums in Southern California, seem to indicate that the problems of illegally looted artefacts within US institutions run deeper than indicated by the many recent high profile restitution cases across the country. Despite supposed crackdown on behaviour of dubious legality by museums, many continued to purchase un-provenanced artefacts.

Los Angeles Times

Raids suggest a deeper network of looted art
Even after scandals, Southland museums pursued suspect artifacts, warrants say.
By Jason Felch, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer
January 25, 2008

Coordinated raids on four Southern California museums early Thursday suggest that the involvement of art institutions in the purchase of looted objects is far more extensive than recent high-profile scandals have indicated.

Even as the country’s most prominent museums were embarrassed by revelations of stolen artifacts in their collections, several local museums continued to pursue objects they had reason to believe were taken illegally from Thailand, Myanmar, China and Native American sites within the United States, according to search warrants served Thursday.

Dozens of federal agents descended on the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, Pasadena’s Pacific Asia Museum, the Bowers Museum in Santa Ana and Mingei International Museum in San Diego.

The raids marked the first public move in a five-year undercover investigation of the alleged smuggling pipeline.

Museum officials defended their practices and pledged to cooperate fully in the investigations.

The detailed warrants gave the agents broad authority to search the museums’ galleries, offices, storage areas and computer archives. They were looking for objects and records related to the primary targets of the investigation: an alleged art smuggler, Robert Olson, and the owner of a Los Angeles Asian art gallery, Jonathan Markell. Markell’s Silk Roads Gallery on La Brea Avenue was also raided.

No arrests were made, but legal experts say the surprise search warrants suggest prosecutors are collecting the final elements to seek criminal indictments against Markell and Olson.

The action comes after several years in which the art world has been hammered by claims from Italy and Greece that major American museums — most prominently the J. Paul Getty Museum — purchased art that had been stolen from and smuggled out of those countries.

The Getty agreed last year to return 40 of its most prized objects, following similar deals by museums in Boston and New York. The Getty’s former antiquities curator is on trial in Rome, accused of knowingly buying looted art, a charge she denies.

This case could go further. The warrants served Thursday show prosectors have carefully laid a foundation for the possible indictment of museum staffers allegedly complicit in the looting schemes — which would be a first under American law, experts say.

The warrants are based on a five-year undercover investigation by an unnamed agent with the National Park Service, who presented himself to Olson and Markell as an eager collector.

Olson and Markell told the undercover investigator they regularly bought Thai antiquities from looters and smugglers, sometimes smuggling them personally, the warrants state. They then allegedly sold them to clients in Los Angeles. They also admitted running an elaborate donation scheme, selling their clients looted artifacts with forged appraisals that inflated the value of the objects by as much as 400%, the warrants state. They then allegedly helped these clients donate the objects to local museums, which provided a tax write off at the inflated value.

The scheme appears to have spanned the last decade and generally involved repeated donations of objects with values of just under $5,000, the value at which the IRS required additional documentation.

In the case of the Bowers and the Pacific Asia Museum, the warrants clearly suggest that officials were aware that the objects were looted and overvalued but accepted them anyway.

A senior curator at the Bowers Museum, now deceased, regularly accepted donations of Thai and Native American antiquities from Olson that he knew were removed illegally, the warrants say. The documents describe the longtime curator, Armand Labbé, smiling and chuckling as he told the agent he could accept the donations because “he could not determine” what rules the museum was supposed to follow.

The Bowers’ current director, Peter Keller, told the undercover agent he knew Olson and had visited his warehouse. An appraiser, described as Labbé’s girlfriend, told the agent that she regularly prepared appraisals of objects for Keller to donate to his own museum. Keller denied wrongdoing Thursday.

In the case of the Pacific Asia Museum in Pasadena, the agent met with two museum officials in in November 2005 and offered to donate Thai material he had purchased from Markell.

Marcia Page, the museum’s deputy director of collections, told the agent that given her position, she was “expected to at least put up token resistance to accepting antiquities without proper paperwork,” the warrant states. She noted that Markell had donated Thai material, and that she didn’t think it was legal. She said more senior people in the museum would have to sign the paperwork.

About two weeks later, Page told the agent that the bulk of his donation had been accepted.

LACMA, the Mingei and the UC Berkeley Art Museum all received similar donations from Markell or Olson over several years, the warrants say, but the documents are unclear about the extent to which museum officials knew of alleged theft or tax evasion.

According to the warrants, Markell at one point told the agent that LACMA was “a stickler” for checking the background of pieces. But the dealer also suggested the museum had pursued objects it knew were looted in the past.

“They knew,” Markell said of one artifact LACMA wanted that was taken out of Thailand after a law prohibiting exporting such items was passed there, according to the warrants. “Markell said that LACMA had found a loophole, but he was not clear on what that loophole was.”

The 150 pages of warrants filed Thursday paint a picture of rampant fraud and theft.

The charges that follow could include receiving stolen property, import violations and tax fraud. In particular, the warrants show that authorities are building a case that the looted antiquities should be considered stolen property under American law. Thailand has claimed state ownership of all artifacts since 1961, and American law would recognize that claim if certain conditions are met, said Marcia Isaacson, a former New York federal prosecutor who won a pivotal antiquities conviction several years ago.

The investigation targets art allegedly stolen from Thailand, China, Myanmar and Native American archeological sites that ended up in museums across the Southland.

The contested objects are far less valuable than those returned by the Getty but they are far more numerous, and some of the alleged conduct by museum officials, contained in hours of tape-recorded meetings, appears equally troubling.

Many come from the ancient civilization of the Ban Chiang, which occupied northeastern Thailand from 1000 BC to AD 200. “The original location where Ban Chiang culture was discovered was named a World Heritage Site in 1992 and is considered the most important prehistoric settlement yet discovered in Southeast Asia,” the warrants say.

The warrants allege that the Ban Chiang objects are probably looted because they were first excavated by archeologists in 1967, six years after Thailand banned the export of antiquities.

The Thai government never gave permission for the contested antiquities to leave the country. Moreover, importing such objects into the United States after 1979 was a violation of the U.S. National Stolen Property Act and the Archeological Resource Protection Act, the warrants state.

Other objects named in the warrants came from Burma (also known as Myanmar), from which the U.S. has banned imports since 2003, and China, which has strict export laws governing its antiquities. There are also objects allegedly stolen from Native American sites in the U.S., the sale of which are controlled by federal laws.

The investigation began in 2003, when the undercover agent with the National Park Service posed as a buyer and began purchasing looted art from Olson, according to the warrants. Olson, the warrants say, specializes in Native American and Thai anti- quities.

Olson allegedly told the agent he had been importing objects from Ban Chiang since the 1980s and had never received a permit from the Thai government. He said he got objects “as they were being dug up” and knew it was illegal to ship them out of the country, the warrants say.

The smuggled antiquities were affixed with “Made in Thailand” labels, and sometimes painted over, to make them look to U.S. customs officials like modern replicas, Olson allegedly told the agent.

Olson also claimed to have the largest collection of Native American ladles anywhere in the world and admitted that he had dug for artifacts on public land in New Mexico without authorization, the warrants state.

In September 2003, federal agents intercepted a shipment from Thailand destined for Olson and Markell. Markell and his wife own Silk Roads Gallery, which sells Asian and Buddhist art. Their website shows the couple in a photo with the Dalai Lama.

Times staff writers Ari Bloomekatz, Paloma Esquivel, Robert Lopez, David Reyes and Richard Marosi contributed to this report.

Philanthropy News Digest

Posted on January 28, 2008
Four California Museums Searched by Federal Agents for Looted Artifacts

Federal agents have raided a Los Angeles gallery and four Southern California museums, including the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, as part of a five-year undercover investigation into the smuggling of looted antiquities from Thailand, Myanmar, China, and Native American sites, the Los Angeles Times reports.

The institutions searched include the Pacific Asia Museum in Pasadena, the Bowers Museum in Santa Ana, the Mingei International Museum in San Diego, and the Silk Roads Gallery in Los Angeles. While looted antiquities from Italy and Greece have been the subject of recent investigations, the raids were a startling development in the ongoing controversy. Detailed warrants gave the agents broad authority to search the museums’ galleries, offices, storage areas, and computer archives, said the Los Angeles Times, and the coordinated nature of the raids, which took place in the early morning, suggest that the involvement of art institutions in the purchase of looted objects is far more extensive than was previously thought.

At the center of the investigation, which is being conducted by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement office, the National Park Service, and the criminal investigation division of the Internal Revenue Service, are Roads Gallery owners Jonathan Markell, his wife, Cari, and Robert Olson. The search warrants and affidavits claim that Olson smuggled looted antiquities out of Thailand, Myanmar, and China, and that the Markells imported them and then arranged to donate them to museums on behalf of clients who took inflated tax deductions for the gifts. In addition, meetings between an undercover agent for the National Park Service posing as a collector and the Markells and representatives of some of the museums were detailed. What’s more, in cases involving at least two institutions — the Bowers and Pacific Asia museums — curators appeared to be aware that the objects they were accepting as donations had been looted or were illegally imported.

Michael Govan, director of the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, said LACMA had in its collections about sixty objects related to the investigation that had been donated by the Markells or other museum members. Govan denied that the museum knew of, or had looked for, ways to get around the ban on imports of certain artifacts and defended the museum’s process for reviewing potential donations. “There is no loophole that we know about,” he said. “If anybody can identify one, we would be the first to close it.”

Felch, Jason. “Raids Suggest a Deeper Network of Looted Art.” Los Angeles Times 1/25/08.

Primary Subject: Arts and Culture
Location(s): California, Los Angeles

Time Magazine Blogs

January 24, 2008 3:12
Raiders of the Looted Artifacts
Posted by Richard Lacayo

They got a rude awakening Thursday morning at four museums in southern California — federal agents on their doorsteps with search warrants. The agents who swarmed the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, the Pacific Asia Museum in Pasadena, the Bowers Museum in Santa Ana and the Mingei International Museum in San Diego were looking for objects and records related to an investigation into an alleged art smuggler, Robert Olson, and Jonathan Markell, the owner of an L.A. gallery that specializes in Asian art, and whose gallery was also raided. The Art Museum of the University of California at Berkeley was also implicated. Jason Felch, the L.A. Times reporter who was one of their specialists on the various travails of the Getty in recent years, has a very speedy story on the Times website.

According to that story, more than four years ago an agent with the National Park Service presented himself to Olson and Markell in the guise of a new collector of Asian art. The warrants claim that the two men admitted that they dealt in objects looted from archeological digs and public sites and sold some to him.

The story goes on to say:

The warrants claim the men also introduced the agent to museum officials who, in dozens of secretly tape-recorded meetings, accepted donations of looted art with values inflated to help the sellers obtain tax write-offs. In the case of the Bowers and the Pacific Asia museums, the warrants clearly suggest that museum officials were aware that the objects were looted and overvalued and accepted them anyway.

LACMA, the Mingei and the UC Berkeley Art Museum all received similar donations from Markell or Olson over several years, the warrants say, but the documents are unclear about the extent to which museum officials knew of alleged theft or tax evasion.

Actually, according to the warrant, Markell told the agent that LACMA was “a stickler” for insisting on proper documentation of items that came into its collection, but according to the Times, Markell “also suggested that the museum had found a loophole to import restrictions on some items.”

But I would say this is the money quote:

The alleged crimes described in the warrants continued amid and after the Getty scandal became public, suggesting some American museums have not changed collecting habits known to be illegal or at least questionable. The new allegations could also carry much more serious consequences for those implicated because they are being investigated by U.S. authorities on American soil.

Which may be another way of saying that the former Getty curator Marion True may not be the last American museum professional who has to do a kind of perp walk.

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

Possibly related articles

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URL

Leave a Comment

We want to hear your views. Be as critical or controversial as you like, but please don't get personal or offensive. Remember this is for feedback and constructive discussion!
Comments may be edited or removed if they do not meet these guidelines. Repeat offenders will be blocked from posting further comments. Any comment deemed libellous by Elginism's editors will be removed.
The commenting system uses some automatic spam detection and occasionally comments do not appear instantly - please do not repost comments if they do not show up straight away