October 13, 2009

Hawass claims that the Louvre knew Egyptian artefacts were looted

Posted at 12:53 pm in Similar cases

More coverage of Zahi Hawass’s threats to cut ties between Egypt & the Louvre, as arguments over disputed artefacts in the French museum escalate. Hawass also alleges that the Louvre knew the artefacts were obtained illegally at the time that they were acquired.

Independent Online (Zaire)

Artefacts drive wedge between Egypt, Louvre
October 08 2009 at 09:18AM
By Paul Schemm

Egypt’s antiquities czar took his campaign to recover the nation’s lost treasures to a new level on Wednesday by cutting ties with one of the world’s premier museums, the Louvre, over disputed artefacts.

The Paris museum’s refusal to return painted wall fragments of a 3 200-year-old tomb near the ancient temple city of Luxor could jeopardise its future excavations in Egypt.

It was the most aggressive effort yet by Zahi Hawass, Egypt’s tough and media savvy chief archaeologist, in his campaign to reclaim what he says are antiquities stolen from the country and purchased by some of the world’s leading museums.

His move appeared to have borne fruit almost immediately. Both the Louvre and France’s Culture Ministry said they were ready to return the pieces.

“The Louvre Museum refused to return four archaeological reliefs to Egypt that were stolen during the 1980s from the tomb of the noble Tetaki,” said a statement quoting Supreme Council of Antiquities chief Hawass.

This was not the first time Hawass cut ties with a museum. He took a similar step against the St. Louis Art Museum after it failed to answer his demand to return a 3 200-year-old golden burial mask of a noblewoman. But taking such an action against an institution of the Louvre’s stature is unprecedented.

Egypt immediately suspended the Louvre’s excavation in the massive necropolis of Saqqara, near Cairo, and cancelled a lecture in Egypt by a former curator from the museum.

Thousands of antiquities were spirited out of the country during Egypt’s colonial period and afterward by archaeologists, adventurers and thieves.

Hawass’ office described the disputed fragments as pieces of a burial fresco showing the nobleman Tetaki’s journey to the afterlife and said thieves chipped them from the walls of the tomb near the Valley of the Kings in the 1980s.

Christiane Ziegler, the former curator of the Louvre’s Egyptology department, acquired the four fragments, according to the antiquities council. She will now not be allowed to give a scheduled lecture in Egypt.

The French said there were five fragments, while the Egyptians report four. There was no way to immediately reconcile the discrepancy.

French Culture Minister Frederic Mitterrand said he believes the artefacts should be returned and the pieces were acquired by the Louvre in “good faith” in 2000 and 2003.

“It wasn’t until November 2008, after archaeologists rediscovered the tomb from which the frescoes appear to have come, that serious doubts emerged about the legality of their removal from Egyptian territory,” a statement from Mitterrand’s office said.

The Louvre’s press office said a national committee made up of specialists from France’s museum world and other experts will meet to decide whether to return the artefacts, with final approval given by the Culture Ministry.

Mitterrand said he asked the committee to meet on Friday.

If the committee favours returning the pieces to Egypt, Mitterrand’s office said he is “ready to immediately return the frescoes to Egyptian authorities.”

The readiness of the museum to work with Hawass could well stem from his total power to determine whose expeditions get to explore the continuing wealth of ancient artefacts in Egypt.

Hawass is well known around the world for his numerous television appearances in his trademark fedora showcasing newly discovered antiquities. Soon after becoming Egyptian antiquities head, he declared that Egypt was not deal with any museum purchasing or exhibiting what Egypt considered stolen artefacts.

Hawass has drawn up a list of high profile items he wants back including another piece held by the Louvre, the painted ceiling of the Dendera temple showing the Zodiac.

At the top of his list are the bust of Nefertiti – wife of the famed monotheistic Pharaoh Akhenaten – and the Rosetta Stone, a basalt slab with an inscription that was the key to deciphering Egyptian hieroglyphics. The bust is in Berlin’s Egyptian Museum; the Rosetta Stone is in the British Museum in London.

He has also asked for the return of the bust of Achhaf, the builder of the Chephren Pyramid from the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, and a statue of the Hemiunu, the nephew of Pharaoh Khufu from Germany’s Roemer-Pelizaeu museum.

He says so far he has recovered 5 000 artefacts since becoming antiquities head in 2002.

In one of the most acrimonious fights, Hawass has repeatedly requested the return of a 3 200-year-old golden mask of a noblewoman from the St. Louis Art Museum and has since cut ties with the museum and called on people to boycott its collection.

He recently succeeding in winning the return from France of hair stolen from the mummy of the Pharaoh Ramses II.

The process of repatriating cultural heritage is complicated by inadequate local and international laws and many museums maintain they acquire their artefacts legally and in a transparent manner.

Determining whether an artefact has even been stolen requires delicate cooperation between government, law enforcement, museums, and antiquities dealers. And frequently, there are gaps in the historical records.


Louvre Knew Ancient Egyptian Items Were Stolen, Hawass Says
By Alaa Shahine

Oct. 8 (Bloomberg) — The Louvre museum bought five ancient Egyptian mural paintings even though it knew they were stolen, Egypt’s top archaeologist said today, escalating his criticism of the French institution.

Egypt said yesterday it has suspended co-operation with the Louvre, saying the Paris museum refused to return the items, which it said were stolen from Luxor in 1980.

“When we found the Louvre was stalling we had to apply the rules and laws,” Zahi Hawass, secretary-general of the Supreme Council of Antiquities, said in an e-mailed statement.

Hawass has been campaigning since 2002 to recover Egyptian antiquities located abroad, including the bust of Queen Nefertiti in Berlin’s Neues Museum, which opens next week, and the Rosetta stone at the British Museum in London.

France’s culture ministry, which oversees the museum, said yesterday in a statement that Culture Minister Frederic Mitterrand favors the return of what it described as “five fresco fragments” from the tomb of an Egyptian prince.

The fragments of mural painting were “acquired in good faith” by the Louvre in 2000 and 2003, the e-mailed statement said. Only in November 2008, when archaeologists discovered the tomb where they came from, did “serious doubts” emerge on the “legality” of their removal from Egypt, the ministry said.

The National Scientific Commission for the Museum Collections of France will meet on Oct. 9 to discuss the provenance of the frescoes, the ministry said, and if it agrees, the items will be returned to the Egyptian authorities.

To contact the writer on the story: Alaa Shahine in Cairo

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

Possibly related articles

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

RSS feed for comments on this post

Leave a Comment

We want to hear your views. Be as critical or controversial as you like, but please don't get personal or offensive. Remember this is for feedback and constructive discussion!
Comments may be edited or removed if they do not meet these guidelines. Repeat offenders will be blocked from posting further comments. Any comment deemed libellous by Elginism's editors will be removed.
The commenting system uses some automatic spam detection and occasionally comments do not appear instantly - please do not repost comments if they do not show up straight away