February 27, 2014
The Parthenon Marbles & the National Gallery director
I don’t quite know what to make of this article. On the one hand he’s saying that the Parthenon Marbles could return to Greece, which is great. On the other hand though, he is saying that they must not become pawns of political exploitation & that the issue over where they belong must not become an obsession. Its hard to see how these can be separated out though – its almost saying that they would only be returned if Greece wasn’t really interested in them.
He then talks about how they would not be displayed on the monument – but this is not something that anyone has sensibly proposed for a long time now. The New Acropolis Museum was designed & constructed especially for this purpose & the way in which it relates to the original building has already been discussed many times on this site.
National Gallery director Nicholas Penny
From:
Greek Reporter
Great Britain Challenges Greece on Elgin Marbles
by Iro-Anna Mamakouka – Feb 24, 2014The director of London’s National Gallery, Nicholas Penny, is challenging Greece once more on the issue of the Parthenon’s Marbles, suggesting that Greece and Britain share them.
According to him, the British Museum has recognized to some extent, the profound importance that the Marbles have for Greece and that lending the Marbles to the Greek state is under discussion as long as they do not become pawns of political exploitation.
He also suggested that the British Museum would be open to discussion over sharing the Elgin Marbles provided that the issue of where they really belong does not become an obsession.Moreover, Mr. Penny claimed that if the Marbles were to return to Greece, they would not be placed on the monument due to Athens’ air pollution. Both the monument and the marbles are not in very good condition; thus, the visitors could not see them as they were in their original position. According to Mr. Penny, this is a sentimental myth, the idea that someone can turn the clock backwards.
- A new gallery for the Elgin Marbles? : November 24, 2007
- Controversy over Parthenon Marbles hits Liverpool gallery : January 29, 2004
- The Elgin Marbles & the 2012 Olympic bid : June 11, 2005
- Are the Elgin Marbles really “yesterday’s question”? : July 10, 2009
- Why Britain must re-think the Parthenon Marbles issue : October 27, 2008
- Guns yes, Marbles no : February 3, 2004
- Saving antiquities for the Nation : November 12, 2003
- Marbles Reunited statement on Russia Parthenon Marbles loan : December 6, 2014
newsnewscom said,
02.27.14 at 2:13 pm
RT @elginism: Blog post: Because you want them you can’t have them – The Parthenon Marbles & Nicholas Penny http://t.co/3MVasFs1EC
MinogueTom said,
02.27.14 at 2:22 pm
@elginism Pier owned by Elgin’s at Limekilns Fife. 7th Earl took Parthenon marbles as Greeks couldn’t care for them! http://t.co/8ZKOk3dS6x
milagergova said,
02.27.14 at 2:35 pm
RT @elginism: Blog post: Because you want them you can’t have them – The Parthenon Marbles & Nicholas Penny http://t.co/3MVasFs1EC
Gregoria3003 said,
02.27.14 at 3:16 pm
RT @elginism: Blog post: Because you want them you can’t have them – The Parthenon Marbles & Nicholas Penny http://t.co/3MVasFs1EC
VasTheGreek said,
02.27.14 at 3:19 pm
RT @elginism: Blog post: Because you want them you can’t have them – The Parthenon Marbles & Nicholas Penny http://t.co/3MVasFs1EC
MaretStella said,
02.27.14 at 7:34 pm
@MinogueTom @elginism Surely U jest?
Basil2744 said,
02.27.14 at 7:36 pm
@MinogueTom @elginism The man is historically ILLITERATE. It is easier to make a fool of yourself that educate yourself.
MaretStella said,
02.27.14 at 7:44 pm
@elginism I just wonder what the marbles are doing to the fengshui or vastu of Athens& greece.?
MinogueTom said,
02.27.14 at 7:45 pm
@MaretStella @elginism Jest about what. The pier?
PaulRed82sed said,
02.27.14 at 7:47 pm
@MinogueTom @elginism. They were never Elgin‘s to remove. What Greece did with them was‘nt his business.
MinogueTom said,
02.27.14 at 7:56 pm
@PaulRed82sed @elginism Preaching to the converted http://t.co/OXmA7RDmMI
MinogueTom said,
02.27.14 at 7:57 pm
@Basil2744 @elginism Preaching to the converted http://t.co/OXmA7RDmMI
MinogueTom said,
02.27.14 at 7:59 pm
@MaretStella @elginism http://t.co/OXmA7RDmMI
MaretStella said,
02.27.14 at 11:01 pm
@MinogueTom @elginism profuse apologies had not understood correctly – polar vortex of long Canadian winter again
MinogueTom said,
02.28.14 at 8:33 am
@MaretStella @elginism Polar vortex eh? No problems twitter is made for misunderstandings.
Nihil_Novi_Net said,
02.28.14 at 7:24 pm
The Parthenon Marbles & the National Gallery director – Elginism http://t.co/Y6nv58AfB0