January 5, 2011

Why Africa’s looted art must be returned

Posted at 1:44 pm in Similar cases

Many African artefacts are in museums & private collections around the world & a significant proportion of these were acquired in circumstances of dubious legality. Many people think that some of these artefacts should be returned, but so far, campaigns have been relatively unsuccessful.

Modern Ghana

Africa’s masterpieces must be returned
Source: The Herald
Africa | 15 hours ago

The restitution of a work of art or record to the country of origin enables a people to recover part of their memory and identity.

This pressing and contentious issue of the return and restitution of Africa’s looted art, antiques and cultural heritage, from today’s custodians of Euro-American museums, is one that requires urgent attention and government intervention of every African nation.

According to the International council of Museums ICOM, “The looting of archeological items and the destruction of archaeological sites in Africa are a cause of irreparable damage to African history and hence, to the history of human kind.

Whole sections of our history have been wiped out and can n ever be re-constituted.”

For many enlightened Africans, the issue of restitution and its lack of resolution are indicative of the unequal relations between the West and Africa.

African antiquity in the US
Recently, this writer was privy to an exhibition of African antiquities at the Dallas Museum of Art (D.M.A.) belonging to the McDermott family. The oldest work of African art in the D.M.A. Collection, including that of Ancient Egypt, dates from the 8th Millennium B.C., whilst that of Sub-Saharan Africa dates from the 1st Millennium, B.C.

The objects in this collection include zoomorphic terra cotta figures from the Nok Civilisation in Nigeria, terra cotta heads from Lydenburg in the Mpumalanga Province of South Africa, and some “Ziwa” Divining bowls from Zimbabwe, as well as rare terra cotta fertility dolls.

This also include double headed royal headrests “mitsago” from the Munhumutapa dynasty, latticed in gold leaf and dating back to the 11th century. It was indeed a revelation!

African antiquity in the UK
In Europe, the British Museum’s “African, Oceania and America” section held and exhibition in May and June this year, of over 600 pieces of art from Africa, specially from traditional culture of Nigeria, to coincide with Nigeria’s 50th Independence Anniversary, which fell on 1st October, 2010.

These works which were exhibited in London, were also shown in Spain, and will travel on a North American tour until April 2012, to the Houston Museum of Fine Arts, The Indianapolis Museum of Art and the Museum of African Art, in New York. Regrettably, nowhere in this schedule is there an exhibition to be held in any African country, including Nigeria, the main cultural host of the material on exhibit.

The way forward
For Africans to progress, the issue of restitution, we must be aware that there are various legal instruments and structured forums for dialogue and arbitration. In the 2007, 14th session of the Unesco Intergovernmental committee for promoting the return of Cultural Property to its countries of origin held a meeting.

Representatives from Greece, Turkey and Mozambique joined the committee.

Greece pressed for the return of the Parthenon’s Elgin Marbles from Britain, while Turkey wanted the return of the Bogazkoy Sphinx from Germany, and Mozambique, the return of the Makonde Mask from Switzerland.

In 2005, the Italian Government returned an Ethiopian Obelisk, preceded by the return of one of the Zimbabwean National soapstone birds by Germany, in 2003, at an African art exhibition in Belgium.

However, Zimbabwean art and cultural scholars need to be more vocal about the return of other pieces of antiquity that were looted by the pioneers and their followers.

The following objects of National significance and aesthetic value, were collected in colonial raids in present day Zimbabwe. These include:

l The Zimbabwean copper Fiscal Ingots from Guruve and Mhangura,

l The Mapungubwe golden plated wooden serving bowls, scepters and ornamentation.

l Copper coinage of Sultan Al Hassan Bin Sulaiman of Kilwa, southern Tanzania, from Great Zimbabwe.

l The set of 10 golden rhinoceros from Mapela, Mapungubwe, near the Limpopo River, have not been located since their discovery in 1953, during the Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasaland.

l Lastly, the Zimbabwe birds, reputedly 10 in number; a figure of completeness in Shona ethonumerical etymology — “Gumi” (ten) is derived from “kuguma” to be complete or “whole”.

l If so, where are the other 5 Zimbabwean Birds?
Some researches have said there are in a private collection belonging to the Rhodes Estate, in South Africa, others have said there are in a museum warehouse in Hackney, North London.

Whilst these assumptions may not be substantiated, it is worth establishing their presence.

As articulated by ICOM, “Objects cannot be understood once they have been removed from their archeological context and divorced from the whole to which they belong”.

African scholars and cultural workers need to research and reclaim our heritage.

African art ranks amongst the most technically sophisticated and aesthetically remarkable in the history of world. The reclamation process can start by making forays into the British Museum.

“The museum is a huge repository of impressive collections from former colonised societies, and in that sense, the Museum mirrors the trail of the extent of the empire and the plundering of spoils.”

Perhaps one should start by creating dialogue with them, to return stolen iconic treasures to post-colonial Africa. It is our duty, especially given the current indigenous empowerment drive.
Source: http://www.herald.co.zw/inside.aspx?sectid=19648&cat=3

Why Africa's looted art must be returned, 5.0 out of 5 based on 1 rating
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 5.0/5 (1 vote cast)

Possibly related articles

Tags: , , , , , , , ,


  1. wordbender said,

    01.07.11 at 6:24 pm

    “According to the International council of Museums ICOM, “The looting of archaeological items and the destruction of archaeological sites in Africa are a cause of irreparable damage to African history and hence, to the history of human kind. ”

    Hang on a minute, the looting IS the history of Africa and of human kind.

  2. Joe said,

    08.07.11 at 7:16 pm

    Elginism “An act of cultural vandalism”

    Selective memory – Had Lord Elgin not bought them from the Turks (the legal government at the time) they would probably have been burned and converted into agricultural lime by local farmers

  3. Matthew said,

    08.07.11 at 8:15 pm

    That’s a misleading post-rationalised argument.
    At the time that Elgin removed the marbles, he never made any mention of protecting / saving them. That was only a back-story he later used to support his actions.
    Elgin removed only half the surviving sculptures – if the others were at such risk, the implication is that there would be nothing now left to exhibit in the Acropolis Museum (which is not the case).

  4. NGITIR VICTOR B. said,

    08.27.11 at 3:11 pm

    The issue of looted and plundered African art is gruesome. I would like to be regularly informed about calls for papers, fellowships, scholarships and training programs on the subject of African antiquities. My PhD thesis to be defended in December 2011 is entitled “Bamenda Grassfields Royal Collections and Museums from Ancient Times to the Beginning of the 21st Century: Symbolisms and Conservation of Palace Art”. The problem of Africa’s looted art is capital in my work. We have numerous case studies in Cameroon.
    Art Historian/Museologist

RSS feed for comments on this post

Leave a Comment

We want to hear your views. Be as critical or controversial as you like, but please don't get personal or offensive. Remember this is for feedback and constructive discussion!
Comments may be edited or removed if they do not meet these guidelines. Repeat offenders will be blocked from posting further comments. Any comment deemed libellous by Elginism's editors will be removed.
The commenting system uses some automatic spam detection and occasionally comments do not appear instantly - please do not repost comments if they do not show up straight away